Taxation in Case of Bitcoin

FAQs on Bitcoins - Their Taxation and other related issues

1.	What are Crypto Currencies?
	Crypto Currencies are decentralized virtual or digital currencies which are neither issued by any Central Bank nor are backed up by any Government. These currencies are quite popular because they provide secure and anonymous way of remittance of money and entering into a transaction. In other words, these currencies are as good as fiat currencies (i.e., legal tenders issued by the Govt. of any Country) and are acceptable as a mode of payment by some entities. By September 2017, over a thousand crypto currencies were found to exist.
2.	What is a Bitcoin?
	Bitcoin is a type of Crypto Currency that was created in 2009 by an unknown person using the alias, Satoshi Nakamoto. New Bitcoins are generated by a competitive and decentralized process called as 'Mining'. In this mining process, individuals process the transactions and secure the network by using specialized hardware and in exchange they are awarded new Bitcoins.
3.	Is trading in Bitcoin legal?
	The RBI has neither declared the crypto currencies as illegal not it has accepted these as legal tenders. Further, RBI has clarified that it has not given any licence or authorisation to any entities to operate such schemes or deal with Bitcoins or any virtual currency. RBI has rather cautioned people about the risks associated with virtual currencies.
4.	Whether Bitcoin is a currency?
	In common parlance, a currency means anything which is used as a circulating medium and is generally accepted in trade circles as a representative of value of property.
	The term "Currency" has also been defined inclusively in the FEMA Act, 1999. It includes currency notes, postal notes, postal orders, money orders, cheques, drafts, travellers cheques, letters of credit, bills of exchange and promissory notes, credit cards or such other similar instruments, as may be notified by the RBI.
	As various entities accept Bitcoins as a mode of payment, it seems that Bitcoin is a currency. However, there is another school of thought that thinks since it has not been termed as currency in FEMA Act or as legal tender by the RBI, it may not qualify as currency.
	Whether a Bitcoin would be classified as currency or not would be a matter of dispute and arguments until RBI clears its stand on it. If RBI declares that Bitcoin is a currency, any trading in it would be subject to FEMA Regulations.
5.	Whether nature of gain derived from sale of Bitcoinsis Capital Gain or Business Income?
	In view of Section 2(14) of the Income-tax, Act 1961, a capital asset means a property of any kind held by a person, whether or not connected with his business or profession. The term 'property', though has no statutory meaning, yet it signifies every possible interest which a person can acquire, hold or enjoy.
	Therefore, Bitcoins could be deemed as capital assets if they are purchased for the purpose of investments by the taxpayers.Therefore, any gain arising on transfer of a Bitcoin shall be taxable as capital gains.
	However, if the transactions in bitcoins are substantial and frequent, it could be held that the taxpayer is trading in bitcoins. In this case, income from sale of Bitcoins would be taxable as business income.
6.	How to compute capital gains from sale of Bitcoins?
	If gains arising from transfer of Bitcoins are treated as capital gains, their further classification in to short-term or long-term gain would depend upon the period of holding of Bitcoins.
	If a Bitcoinis held for more than 36 months from the date of purchase, it will be considered as long-term capital asset, otherwise a short-term capital asset.
	Short-term capital gainsare taxable as per the slab rates applicable to a taxpayer.And long-term capital gainsare taxed at the flat rate of 20% with the benefit of indexation.
7.	Whether Bitcoins earned during 'Mining' process are also taxable?
	If profits earned from Bitcoins are taxable as business income, then the Bitcoins earned in the 'mining' process are also taxable as business profits. However, if Bitcoins are classified as capital assets, the virtual currency earned from Bitcoin 'Mining' may not be charged to tax.
	Bitcoins generated during the 'mining' process are classifiable as self-generated capital assets. Since, the cost of acquisition of such Bitcoins is not available, the taxpayer can take the benefit of judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of B.C. Srinivasa Setty [1981] 5 Taxman 1 (SC). In this case it was held that if cost of acquisition of an asset cannot be ascertained, the machinery provision for computation of capital gains will fail, therefore, no capital gains can be levied on transfer of such assets. Therefore, Bitcoins generated in the 'mining' process may be exempt from tax.
8.	Where are the Bitcoins are deemed to be situated for Income-tax purposes?
	Bitcoins are intangible assets. For Income-tax purposes, situs of an intangible asset may vary according to their nature and obligations attached with them. Situs of intangible properties is well decided on the basis of law of the land where the protection to the property is sought.
	Situs of an intangible can be linked with such tangible properties with which they are most closely connected. For example, a copyright has nexus with the book or other work in respect of which copyright is sought for. The patents are associated with plant and machinery; a trademark or brand name is associated with goods.
	Thus, Situs of Bitcoin can be linked with the country where its operating server is located.
9.	Whether sale of Bitcoin by a Non-resident through Indian Bitcoin Exchange would be charged to tax in India?
	Situs of a property plays an important role in determining the taxability of capital gains arising from sale of that property. Since Bitcoin is an intangible asset, income accruing or arising from its transfer outside India by a person who is not a resident in India cannot be taxed in India. Hence, Sale of Bitcoins by a Non-Resident through an Indian Bitcoin exchange may not be charged to tax.
10.	Whether Bitcoin is Goods or service?
	If Bitcoins are classified as currencies, then it will be considered as 'Money' in CGST Act and no GST could be charged on its trading. However, exchange of a Bitcoin to Indian Rupees(INR) might be considered as service for the purpose of levy of GST under the category of 'Financial Services'.
	In this situation, if the supplier charges any commission for providing of an exchange services, the GST shall be payable at the rate of 18% on the amount of commission. If no consideration is being charged for the services, the supplier shall be liable to pay GST at the rate of 18% on the 1% of gross amount of INR paid by the recipient for such services of exchage.
	There is a conflicting view also. If Bitcoin is not considered as currency, any trading in Bitcoin would be considered as 'Service'. Therefore, supplier (who is selling the Bitcoin) might be required to pay GST at the rate of 18% on the total value charged by him from the buyer of Bitcoin.
11.	What is the taxability on Bitcoins'Mining' under GST?
	In Bitcoin 'mining' process, the individuals process the transactions and secure the network by using specialized hardware and in exchange they are awarded new Bitcoins.
	In other words, Bitcoin is a consideration awarded to the individuals in lieu of their services to secure the Bitcoin Network. Therefore, the Bitcoin 'miners' might be required to pay the GST on the fair market value of the Bitcoin at the rate of 18%.
12.	Whether Govt. of India can legislate to control Bitcoins?
	As per the Constitution of India, 1950 (Entry 36 and 46 of List I of the Seventh Schedule) states that the Central Government is allowed to legislate in respect of currency, coinage, legal tender, foreign exchange and bills of exchange, cheques, promissory notes and other like instruments respectively. Therefore, if RBI states that a Bitcoin is a currency then the Govt. of India can legislate to control the trading of Bitcoin.
13.	Whether Bitcoin is a Pre-Paid Instrument?
	Banks are authorized to issue three kinds of pre-paid payment instruments:
	A. Closed System Payment Instruments
	B. Semi-closed System Payment Instruments
	C. Open System Payment Instruments.
	While, NBFCs and other persons have been authorized to issue only Semi-closed System Payment Instruments (like e-wallets).
	This means that the issuer of a pre-payment instrument must either bea bank, NBFC or a 'person'. Therefore, Bitcoin issued by the software cannot be classified as pre-paid instruments since a server or software cannot be termed as a 'person'.
	Further, a pre-paid instrument has pre-determined and absolute value, whereas the value of a Bitcoin is determined by market speculation, which can either be less or more than its previous original purchase value. Therefore, it cannot be said that the value stored in the Bitcoinrepresents the value paid by the holders. Hence, it cannot be considered as a prepaid instrument.
14.	Is it possible to receive export proceeds in Bitcoins?
	Cross border transactions which involve money consideration shall attract the provisions of FEMA and Rules made there under. FEMA Regulations prescribe that the export proceeds should be received in India only in any of the notified foreign currencies (i.e., USD, Pound, Euro, etc.)
	Unless there is a clear directions from the RBI with regard to legality of Bitcoin or recognition of Bitcoin as a foreign currency, it is not possible to receive payment in Bitcoins to settle the export outstanding.
15.	Is it possible to pay for imports in Bitcoins?
	The FEMA Regulations prescribe tha tpayment for imports should be made in foreign currency only. Unless there is a clear directions from the RBI with regard to legality of Bitcoin or recognition of Bitcoin as foreign currency, it is not possible to make payment in Bitcoin for imports.
16.	Whether trading in Bitcoin falls under current account transaction under FEMA?
	The current account transaction includes all transactions which are not capital in nature, inter-alia, remittance for import of goods or services or remittance for personal purposes, etc. The question whether dealing in Bitcoinis a current account transaction or not wholly depends on whether Bitcoin is a 'good' or an 'asset. If it is not a good, then foreign transactions in Bitcoin shall be treated as capital account transactions and any dealing in Bitcoin would require prior approval from the RBI

--